And to make use of your example, we and additionally have a tendency to play with nouns just like the adjectives

One of several reviewer’s issues was that the guide described “my” etc because determiners, once they have been actually (within his advice) pronouns

– I actually do go along with you on the keeping terms to a minimum in the sessions, and i grant you you to students tend to be browsing learn what adjectives try than simply determiners.

Actually, I believe I simply make reference to “my”an such like while the possessives should your need comes up, and that is not that tend to (they won’t seem to end in of several damage to Shine learners, at the very least). But course books sometimes relate to determiners, thus i have to be in a position to establish them.

The idea I became and make so you can Syed Usman is actually that it is unsafe to talk inside absolutes for the words. Just because their code area and mine refer to “my” etcetera as the determiners and you can “mine” an such like once the “possessive pronouns” this doesn’t mean that somebody more talking about “my” etc because possessive pronouns are always completely wrong. That is undoubtedly exactly how many linguists relate to him or her, eg.

We examined it the hard ways. I experienced only composed a blog post to own my personal blogs toward determiners and you may pronouns, when i noticed an extremely (unfairly in my view) worst report on an enthusiastic EFL sentence structure guide to the a blogs with a clearly linguistics angle. Whenever i dared to help you review that the was certainly fundamental into the EFL, the guy quoted Huddleston and you will Pullum from the myself, and i also obtained a lecture regarding “determinatives” (that i got never ever been aware of – neither In my opinion, have many people).

Whenever i try instead worried I would first got it every incorrect within the my article, I did so some research towards the entire determiner / determinative issue (it is some chaos), and therefore my mention of those two source books. But i have you to definitely strong idea on my site, that is which i use the popular terminology from EFL, so I am sticking with the standard EFL and you may dictionary concept of determiner I would personally already made use of, and you will making the newest unusual and you will great content into linguists..

I agree. In the event that somebody questioned exactly what a good determiner is, I might only provide them with an email list. BTW for the Hungarian, possession is carried out having noun endings not independent terms and conditions.

It doesn’t matter what I think of it, ‘Mine and Greg’s’ appears to be correct

Basic is whatsyourprice free, you have the target, which is the ‘child.’ And then you have the one or two possessors, ‘Greg,’ and the pronoun to own ‘yourself.’ Depending on and that people you are creating when you look at the, the situation of this operation may vary. Very first person is awful with compound possessives!

Take it which have a grain regarding sodium; my ultra-super-chill qualifications lay during the of several treacherous and you will unedited regions away from Fanfiction; I wouldn’t be shocked easily are looking at this entirely in reverse!

Also, when in doubt, try saying the newest phrase aloud. ‘My and you will Greg’s child’ against ‘Mine and Greg’s child’–what type audio most readily useful? You understand which one I would squeeze into. Simply sayin’.

– there lies the main state: it is uncertain separate of if or not i use ‘my’ or ‘mine’. (I observe that inside my basic opinion I’d thought it had been talking of a single boy,but toward 2nd glance I would personally well envision a couple of was indeed becoming regarded.

Additionally it appears for me abnormal having causes I pointed out prior to. The individual got already drawn the kid/youngsters to school, so presumably know their label(s) – consider only use its labels in place of that it slightly uncomfortable design?

Incidentally I can not accept Ashley:) – in so far as i discover, we about avoid using possessive pronouns till the individual otherwise thing has been said (except maybe in book titles). “Greg’s man and you may mine” could possibly performs, in the event the there two pupils, or even more, however, “Exploit and you may Greg’s child”? I believe not.